The failure pattern that keeps me up at night
Tool returned an error.
Agent reported success.
P1 incident. Payment service down. The ticket was never created. The agent said it was.
Step 4: create_incident_ticket
error: "TicketSystemError: Authentication token expired. Ticket was NOT created."
Agent response at step 7: "Incident ticket created and on-call engineer has been notified."
judge_trace result
F 0.20 / 1.0 Broken
Root cause: The agent received an explicit tool error at step 4, skipped error handling entirely, paged the engineer with a fabricated incident ID, then reported success to the user.
Fix: Mandatory error check after every tool call. On failure, halt and report to the user. Never fabricate a success state.